Wednesday, July 17, 2013

J.K. Rowling: Father of Two and Unknown Author Who Receives Rejection Letters

The recent news of J.K. Rowling’s clever little deception with her latest book has readers and writers everywhere all abuzz. Her new book, THE CUCKOO’S CALLING, a mystery, was published under the pseudonym Robert Galbraith to allow her to “publish without hype or expectation” as she told the Sunday Times of London. Rowling’s hope was to get truthful feedback on her novel, without her famous name swaying the reactions of reviewers and readers.

Even written by Robert Galbraith, unknown debut author, the book garnered excellent reviews and critics praised it. For a debut author ‘Mr. Galbraith’ should have been thrilled to be published by an imprint of one of the Big Six publishers, especially after being rejected by at least one other publisher. Yes, Ms. Rowling jumped through all the hoops. She WAS Robert Galbraith, former member of the Royal Military Police and married father of two sons, and unknown writer who gets rejection letters.

And yet all that changed for Mr. Galbraith on Saturday afternoon, July 13th. As a debut author, unknown but the recipient of the kind of reviews all first-time authors dream about, as well as those coveted five-star ratings on Amazon, Mr. Galbraith’s book had only sold 1,500 copies since its publication on April 30, 2013. Now, I would be thrilled to sell 1,500 copies of my debut novel! But, I’m not Robert Galbraith, and I’m sure not J.K. Rowling. Despite all the pieces of the puzzle being in place for him, Robert Galbraith was still unknown, and his book wasn’t topping any charts. Once the truth came out ‘his’ book sped up the best sellers lists and was number one on Amazon by the end of the day, at least here on the west coast of the U.S. In fact, I ordered it a mere two hours after the story broke, and was told I wouldn’t be getting it delivered until August…backordered.

Discoverability. We hear that word all the time as we learn how to promote our debut novels, or even second or third books. Robert Galbraith’s little mystery was chugging along nicely, but he wasn’t exactly a household name. He certainly had not been discovered. In time, he might have been, but the odds were against it. The odds are against any of us getting discovered, of being the author of that next big breakout book. This was the truth that hit me as I read about Rowling’s well-intentioned ruse. I found myself feeling sad for the fictional former member of the Royal Military Police.

So why do we write? Why does the richest woman in Great Britain, the woman who has sold almost as many books as God, continue to write, even going so far as to do so under a pen name? Why do we write when the odds are against any of us becoming the next J.K. Rowling? Because we love to. Because we can’t NOT write. Because to not write would kill us. Yes, we hope people will read what we write. We dream of discovery. But in the end, it doesn’t matter. We will write the books regardless of the outcome. 

I just hope that one day I can be a Robert Galbraith, with wonderful reviews for my book, and sales of 1,500 copies.


  1. Great post, Monica! I am with you when it comes to why I write, but it is sad to know building a readership is a daunting task. The name recognition certainly boosted her sales and gave her an advantage the rest of us don't have. I have to wonder how many would have bought the book if she didn't leak her name? How steadily would her book have sold if she remained Robert Galbraith? Now we will never know.

  2. Thank you Kylie!

    From what I've read she would have preferred to have remained anonymous a little longer--after all she doesn't need to worry about money and sales like the rest of us. And my guess is Robert Galbraith would have continued selling at the same modest rate. Discoverability is a tough one for all debut authors--even fake authors!

  3. Discoverability is the key to any authors success - that and perseverance. Robert Galbraith's sales would have continued to climb, especially if he had a second book out and then a third. At least that's what I keep hearing over and over from people who are getting checks. But Kylie is right, we'll never know what his trajectory would be now.

  4. I wonder if Robert can play Quidditch or if he likes sausage? In all seriousness, Rowling should fire her legal reps because the leak came from them. The down side is how known authors, even under assumed names, are taking more of the pie. Hard to get noticed when the big dogs are always in the way.